Brown mascara gets called “universally flattering” on every product page. It is not. A warm brown scores 91% YAY for Deep Autumn and 28% NAY for Bright Winter. That is not universal — that is a 63-point gap hiding behind one word.
The colored mascara trend is here — brown, burgundy, purple, blue. We scored 9 shades across all 12 color seasons so you can see exactly which ones work on your palette and which ones do not.
Quick Answer
Warm brown mascaras are YAY for Autumn seasons, NAY for Winter seasons. Burgundy and purple mascaras flip that — they are YAY for Winters and Summers. The shade of the mascara matters as much as the category.
Brown Mascaras
Brown is not one shade. A warm, earthy brown reads completely differently from a neutral or ashy brown. The undertone of the brown drives the score more than anything else.
NARS Notorious — Infamous Brown ($28)
| Season | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Light Spring | 55% | OKAY |
| True Spring | 48% | OKAY |
| Bright Spring | 44% | OKAY |
| Light Summer | 55% | OKAY |
| True Summer | 59% | OKAY |
| Soft Summer | 57% | OKAY |
| Soft Autumn | 57% | OKAY |
| True Autumn | 75% | YAY |
| Deep Autumn | 74% | YAY |
| Deep Winter | 71% | YAY |
| True Winter | 62% | OKAY |
| Bright Winter | 58% | OKAY |
The NARS reads as a neutral-leaning brown, which is why it scores moderate across the board and peaks for the deep seasons where the depth match is strong.
ColourPop BFF — Brownie Points ($9)
| Season | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Light Spring | 50% | OKAY |
| True Spring | 53% | OKAY |
| Bright Spring | 53% | OKAY |
| Light Summer | 17% | NAY |
| True Summer | 27% | NAY |
| Soft Summer | 19% | NAY |
| Soft Autumn | 61% | OKAY |
| True Autumn | 89% | YAY |
| Deep Autumn | 91% | YAY |
| Deep Winter | 38% | OKAY |
| True Winter | 32% | NAY |
| Bright Winter | 28% | NAY |
This is the warm brown that the product pages call “universal.” It is not. A 63-point spread between Deep Autumn (91%) and Light Summer (17%) is the opposite of universal. If you are a warm, deep season, this is a drugstore YAY at $9. If you are cool and light, it will look muddy.
Not sure of your season yet? Take the free color quiz — it takes about 2 minutes.
Burgundy & Wine Mascaras
Burgundy is a cool-leaning color family. Even when a burgundy shade has some warmth, the red-wine base pulls cool. That means burgundy mascaras are strongest on Winter seasons — especially Deep Winter, where the depth and cool undertone align.
L'Oreal Voluminous — Deep Burgundy ($11)
| Season | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Light Spring | 17% | NAY |
| True Spring | 19% | NAY |
| Bright Spring | 19% | NAY |
| Light Summer | 50% | OKAY |
| True Summer | 64% | OKAY |
| Soft Summer | 61% | OKAY |
| Soft Autumn | 19% | NAY |
| True Autumn | 39% | OKAY |
| Deep Autumn | 41% | OKAY |
| Deep Winter | 88% | YAY |
| True Winter | 79% | YAY |
| Bright Winter | 73% | YAY |
All three Winter seasons score YAY here. That is rare for a mascara — and it makes this $11 drugstore option one of the strongest Winter mascara picks in our catalog.
Maybelline Sky High — Burgundy Haze ($14)
| Season | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Light Spring | 17% | NAY |
| True Spring | 24% | NAY |
| Bright Spring | 13% | NAY |
| Light Summer | 50% | OKAY |
| True Summer | 61% | OKAY |
| Soft Summer | 61% | OKAY |
| Soft Autumn | 19% | NAY |
| True Autumn | 45% | OKAY |
| Deep Autumn | 32% | NAY |
| Deep Winter | 79% | YAY |
| True Winter | 67% | OKAY |
| Bright Winter | 61% | OKAY |
ColourPop BFF — Wine O'Clock ($9)
Very similar score profile to Burgundy Haze — Deep Winter is the clear winner, all warm seasons score NAY or low OKAY, and the Summers land in comfortable OKAY territory.
Purple Mascaras
Purple mascaras are cool and muted. That combination makes them the opposite of what you might expect — rather than suiting the high-contrast Winters, purple mascara peaks for Soft Summer. The muted chroma is the key: Soft Summer is a muted, cool season, and muted purple lands right in its wheelhouse.
ColourPop BFF — Purple Prose ($9)
| Season | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Light Spring | 16% | NAY |
| True Spring | 16% | NAY |
| Bright Spring | 8% | NAY |
| Light Summer | 48% | OKAY |
| True Summer | 56% | OKAY |
| Soft Summer | 78% | YAY |
| Soft Autumn | 32% | NAY |
| True Autumn | 38% | OKAY |
| Deep Autumn | 23% | NAY |
| Deep Winter | 51% | OKAY |
| True Winter | 42% | OKAY |
| Bright Winter | 40% | OKAY |
L'Oreal Telescopic — Galactic Purple ($15)
Nearly identical score profile to Purple Prose. Soft Summer is the clear winner again. The deeper violet tone nudges Deep Winter slightly higher (51%) but it is still only OKAY.
L'Oreal Voluminous — Deep Violet ($11)
The deepest purple of the three, and the strongest Soft Summer score at 79%. All three purples tell the same story: if you are Soft Summer, purple mascara is your colored-mascara entry point.
Blue Mascara
Maybelline Sky High — Blue Mist ($14)
| Season | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Light Spring | 17% | NAY |
| True Spring | 24% | NAY |
| Bright Spring | 13% | NAY |
| Light Summer | 50% | OKAY |
| True Summer | 61% | OKAY |
| Soft Summer | 61% | OKAY |
| Soft Autumn | 19% | NAY |
| True Autumn | 45% | OKAY |
| Deep Autumn | 32% | NAY |
| Deep Winter | 79% | YAY |
| True Winter | 67% | OKAY |
| Bright Winter | 61% | OKAY |
For a deeper dive into every shade of blue mascara, including cobalt, navy, teal, and sapphire options, see our full blue mascara by season guide.
The Pattern
Here is what the scores reveal when you lay all 9 products side by side:
Warm brown mascara is an Autumn product. True Autumn and Deep Autumn score 75–91% YAY. Cool seasons score 17–38% NAY. It is not universal.
Burgundy mascara is a Winter product. Deep Winter scores 79–88% YAY. All three Springs score NAY. Summers land OKAY.
Purple mascara is a Soft Summer product. Muted cool purple lands 77–79% YAY for Soft Summer and nowhere else breaks 60%. The muted chroma is the differentiator.
Blue mascara scores like burgundy — a cool, deep shade that peaks for Deep Winter.
The takeaway: “colored mascara” is not one trend. It is four different trends with four different season matches. Your season tells you which one is yours.
Search any mascara and see your score
The TruHue app scores any product — scan a barcode in the store, or search by name online.
Try the Free QuizFrequently Asked Questions
Is brown mascara flattering on everyone?
No. A warm brown mascara scores up to 91% YAY for Deep Autumn but only 28% for Bright Winter. The undertone of the brown matters. Warm browns suit Spring and Autumn seasons. Cool-leaning browns (taupe, ash) suit Summer and Winter seasons.
Which colored mascara is best for my color season?
It depends on your season. Warm seasons (Springs and Autumns) do well with warm brown mascaras. Cool seasons (Summers and Winters) do well with burgundy, deep wine, and purple shades. Deep Winter is the strongest season for burgundy mascara. Soft Summer is the top match for purple mascara.
Can warm seasons wear burgundy or purple mascara?
Burgundy and purple mascaras are cool-leaning shades, so they score NAY for most warm seasons. True Autumn can sometimes pull off a deep burgundy as an OKAY (45%), but Light Spring and Bright Spring score below 20% for these shades. Warm seasons are better served by warm brown or black mascara.