Burgundy mascara keeps showing up in “summer 2026 beauty trends” roundups. Every brand from L’Oreal to Pacifica now carries one. The question nobody answers: does it actually work on you, or are you buying a trend that clashes with your coloring?
We scored four burgundy and wine mascaras across all 12 color seasons. The answer is clear — burgundy mascara is a Winter product.
Quick Answer
Burgundy mascara scores 88% YAY for Deep Winter and 73–79% YAY for True Winter and Bright Winter. It scores below 20% NAY for all three Spring seasons. If you are a cool, deep season, burgundy is a strong alternative to black. If you are a warm season, skip it.
The Scores
L’Oreal Voluminous Original — Deep Burgundy ($11)
| Season | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Light Spring | 17% | NAY |
| True Spring | 19% | NAY |
| Bright Spring | 19% | NAY |
| Light Summer | 50% | OKAY |
| True Summer | 64% | OKAY |
| Soft Summer | 61% | OKAY |
| Soft Autumn | 19% | NAY |
| True Autumn | 45% | OKAY |
| Deep Autumn | 41% | OKAY |
| Deep Winter | 88% | YAY |
| True Winter | 79% | YAY |
| Bright Winter | 73% | YAY |
The L’Oreal is the benchmark burgundy. Cool undertone, deep depth, moderate-to-high chroma. The Winters own it. The Summers can wear it. The Springs cannot.
Maybelline Sky High — Burgundy Haze ($14)
| Season | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Light Spring | 17% | NAY |
| True Spring | 22% | NAY |
| Bright Spring | 22% | NAY |
| Light Summer | 44% | OKAY |
| True Summer | 58% | OKAY |
| Soft Summer | 55% | OKAY |
| Soft Autumn | 22% | NAY |
| True Autumn | 44% | OKAY |
| Deep Autumn | 44% | OKAY |
| Deep Winter | 79% | YAY |
| True Winter | 67% | OKAY |
| Bright Winter | 64% | OKAY |
The Maybelline Burgundy Haze is slightly warmer than the L’Oreal, which pulls its Winter scores down a notch. Deep Winter still hits YAY, but True Winter and Bright Winter drop to OKAY. The warmth shift costs it.
Not sure of your season yet? Take the free color quiz — it takes about 2 minutes.
ColourPop BFF — Wine O’Clock ($9)
| Season | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Light Spring | 17% | NAY |
| True Spring | 22% | NAY |
| Bright Spring | 22% | NAY |
| Light Summer | 44% | OKAY |
| True Summer | 58% | OKAY |
| Soft Summer | 55% | OKAY |
| Soft Autumn | 22% | NAY |
| True Autumn | 44% | OKAY |
| Deep Autumn | 44% | OKAY |
| Deep Winter | 76% | YAY |
| True Winter | 64% | OKAY |
| Bright Winter | 61% | OKAY |
Pacifica Stellar Gaze — Stardust ($13)
| Season | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Light Spring | 17% | NAY |
| True Spring | 19% | NAY |
| Bright Spring | 19% | NAY |
| Light Summer | 50% | OKAY |
| True Summer | 64% | OKAY |
| Soft Summer | 61% | OKAY |
| Soft Autumn | 19% | NAY |
| True Autumn | 39% | OKAY |
| Deep Autumn | 41% | OKAY |
| Deep Winter | 88% | YAY |
| True Winter | 79% | YAY |
| Bright Winter | 73% | YAY |
The Pacifica scores identically to the L’Oreal Deep Burgundy. Both are cool-leaning with deep depth. If you want a clean beauty formula with the same color payoff, this is the one.
The Pattern
Every burgundy mascara we tested follows the same shape: Winters are YAY, Summers are OKAY, Springs and Soft Autumn are NAY. The reason is straightforward — burgundy is a cool, deep color. It shares undertone space with the Winter seasons, sits close enough to the Summers, and clashes with the warm, light energy of the Springs.
Season-by-season recommendation:
Deep Winter, True Winter, Bright Winter: Burgundy is your colored mascara. Pick the L’Oreal or Pacifica for the strongest cool lean. This is a YAY.
True Summer, Soft Summer: You can wear it. The scores are OKAY (55–64%). It will not clash, but it will not sing either. Try it as an accent for evening looks.
Light Summer: Borderline. Scores hover around 44–50%. The depth is slightly too heavy for your light coloring. If you want colored mascara, purple may work better.
Springs (all three): Skip. Scores below 22% across the board. Burgundy fights your warm, clear coloring. A warm brown is your colored mascara.
Soft Autumn: Skip. Scores below 22%. Your muted warmth and burgundy’s cool depth do not mix.
True Autumn, Deep Autumn: Borderline OKAY (39–45%). The deep seasons can tolerate burgundy’s depth, but the undertone mismatch keeps it from YAY territory.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can warm seasons wear burgundy mascara?
Most warm seasons score NAY on burgundy mascara. Light Spring, True Spring, and Bright Spring all score below 20%. Soft Autumn scores 19% NAY. True Autumn and Deep Autumn score in the 39–45% OKAY range — wearable but not ideal. If you are a warm season and want colored mascara, warm brown is a much better match.
Which color season looks best in burgundy mascara?
Deep Winter is the top match, scoring 88% YAY on L’Oreal Deep Burgundy and 88% on Pacifica Stardust. True Winter (79% YAY) and Bright Winter (73% YAY) also score well. Burgundy mascara is a Winter product — cool undertone, deep depth, and enough contrast to hold its own on the lash line.
Is burgundy mascara a trend or a keeper?
Burgundy mascara has trended every year since 2024, and the shades keep expanding — L’Oreal, Maybelline, ColourPop, and Pacifica all carry one now. For Winter and deep Summer seasons, it is a keeper — a way to add color to the lash line without going full bright. For Springs, it is a skip.
Which mascara color works on you?
Search any mascara at TruHue and see your score before you buy.
Search products →Keep reading
This post contains affiliate links. TruHue may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Prices may change — check the retailer before you buy.