Quick Answer
Most drugstore reds are made for warm seasons. Of 407 drugstore red lipsticks we checked, 270 suit an Autumn and 211 suit a Spring, but only 14 suit a Summer, and none suit a Light Summer. Summer reds do exist: they are the softest, rosiest reds on the shelf.
After our drugstore red lipstick post, a lot of you asked where your red is, and some of you told us we were wrong. So here is every one of the 407 drugstore reds we measured, on one map. Each dot is a real lipstick in its real color. Tap any dot to see what it is and which seasons it suits.
Score any product for your season — free
Tap a red to see its season
Tap any dot
Each dot is one real lipstick in its measured color. Left to right: cooler to warmer red. Bottom to top: softer to brighter. The dashed lines are where TruHue's scoring splits warm from cool and bright from soft; it also weighs how light or deep a shade is, so position is a guide, not the verdict.
Not sure of your season yet? Take the free color quiz — it takes about 2 minutes.
Why Summer reds are so hard to find
Look at where the dots crowd. The bright, warm corner is packed: the boldest reds on the drugstore shelf are orange-reds, and that is Spring and Autumn territory. Summer is cool and soft, and its corner is the emptiest on the map. Of the 203 boldest, brightest reds, none suit any Summer. Even the shade names tell the story: 90 of these lipsticks have “red”, “cherry”, “ruby” or “scarlet” in the name, and not one of them suits a Summer.
The 14 drugstore reds for True Summer
These are the 14 drugstore reds TruHue scores YAY for True Summer. 4 of them also work for Soft Summer. Light Summers have no drugstore red that is a YAY; a soft rose pink will do the job a red can't.
CoverGirl — 140 Into The Blur
YAY for True Spring, True Summer, True Autumn, Deep Autumn
L'Oréal — Rose Melody (101)
YAY for True Summer, Bright Winter, True Winter
L'Oréal — 120 Major Crush
YAY for True Summer, Soft Summer, Bright Winter, Deep Winter
L'Oréal — 123 Le Nude Independant
YAY for True Summer, True Autumn
Maybelline — Change
YAY for True Spring, Bright Spring, True Summer, Bright Winter
Maybelline — 671 Heated Pink
YAY for True Summer, Bright Winter, True Winter
Milani — 180 Smitten
YAY for True Spring, True Summer, True Autumn, Deep Autumn
NYX Professional Makeup — Matte Rose
YAY for True Summer, Soft Summer, True Winter, Deep Winter
NYX Professional Makeup — 08 Best Buds
YAY for True Spring, True Summer, True Autumn
NYX Professional Makeup — 19 Cannes
YAY for True Spring, True Summer, True Autumn
NYX Professional Makeup — Xxpose Me
YAY for True Spring, True Summer, True Autumn
Revlon — Berry Rich
YAY for True Summer, Soft Summer, True Winter, Deep Winter
ULTA Beauty Collection — Rose Quartz
YAY for True Summer, Soft Summer, True Winter, Deep Winter
ULTA Beauty Collection — Celestial
YAY for True Spring, True Summer, True Autumn, Deep Autumn
Your free 12-season color guide is ready
30 pages of palettes, product picks, and styling tips — matched to your season. Delivered straight to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to receive your free downloads, plus TruHue updates, our newsletter and product recommendations. Unsubscribe anytime.
Frequently asked questions
Can Summers wear red lipstick?
Yes, but only certain reds. Summer reds are soft, cool and rosy, never bright or orange. Of 407 drugstore reds, 14 suit a Summer by TruHue's scoring. Light Summers usually do better with a rose pink than a true red.
What red lipstick suits a True Summer?
A muted, cool rose-red. Among 407 drugstore reds, 14 score YAY for True Summer, including L'Oréal Major Crush, NYX Matte Rose and Revlon Berry Rich. Tap the Summer filter on the map to see them all.
How did you sort the reds into seasons?
Every red was measured from its real color and scored by TruHue's color engine for all 12 seasons. The map places each red by how warm or cool and how bright or soft it is. Seasons are TruHue's scoring: our opinion, backed by data.
Keep Reading
Take TruHue Shopping With You
Scan any barcode in the store and see your YAY, OKAY, or NAY score before you buy. Free on the App Store.
Download the App →Find the red that works for you
Not every red is your red. Score any lipstick for your season before you buy it.
Try TruHue free →